Judge Upholds Michael Vick Decision Regarding Guaranteed Roster Bonuses

Yesterday, Federal District Court Judge David Doty ruled against the NFL owners in their attempt to have him vacate his prior ruling in the Michael Vick case and to disqualify himself as the presiding judge in the case. He ruled that the NFL had provided no valid basis for claiming that he was biased in favor of the players and against the owners, and let stand his prior ruling which allows Michael Vick to retain the guaranteed roster bonuses he earned in 2005 and 2006 despite his suspension last season.

Doty further confirmed the NFLPA’s position that his continuing jurisdiction over the free agency/salary cap system was agreed to by the NFL and the NFLPA as part of their original settlement in 1993, and had to be continued through the term of that settlement unless changed by agreement of the parties.

NFLPA General Counsel Richard Berthelsen stated: “This attack on Judge Doty’s jurisdiction was totally unwarranted and we are very pleased that he denied the owners’ motions. His judicial oversight over the past 15 years has been extremely beneficial for both sides, helping us achieve the longest period of labor peace in our history. Instead of being unjustifiably challenged by the owners for his efforts, he should be commended by them for his considerable contributions to the game.”

- NFL Players.com